Newspaper Association of America Reports Ad Revenue Fell 27.2% in 2009

Newspaper print ad revenue fell 28.6% from last year (which fell 17.7% the year before).  Even more alarming is the fact that newspaper Online advertising revenue fell 11.8% (which fell 1.8% the year before).

Total ad spending in the U.S. fell 12.3% to $125.3 billion in 2009, according to a report from Kantar Media (formerly TNS Media Intelligence).

Internet display advertising was up 7.3%, and free-standing inserts, up 3.0%.

While the economy had an impact in the numbers, clearly, the business model is not working.

Google To Become YellowPages

“I think Google is going to be the new Yellow Pages,” [local business owner and Google advertiser] Mr. Cowie said. “More and more of these younger kids are used to Google. They are looking at their phones rather than opening up a phone book.”

Google’s new enhanced business listings, which it started to test quietly in Houston and San Jose, Calif., early this month, have an obvious competitor: the Yellow Pages. -read the entire post at NYTimes.com

Here is the link to Google Map’s Enhanced Listing page (the yellow tag option is probably not available in your area yet though.

Comscore presents The Internet: Past, Present and Future

It’s a comscore commercial / 10th anniversary video, but they do a good job of showing The Internet: Past, Present and Future in 6minutes. The video includes soundbites by John Battelle, Andrew Braccia, Mark Cuban, Esther Dyson, Wenda Harris Millard, John Markoff, Dave Moore, Tina Sharkey and Fred Wilson. I was not available for comment at the time of this filming.

My tip for the next decade is get your business online and mobile ready – if you are not already (what the hell are you waiting for?). If you have money to invest, put it in the big usa internet stocks, they are the new USA blue chips.

Cyber Monday sales could exceed $900 million this year (2009)

1. If your business is not on the web yet, or your site has not been redesigned in the last 2 years, you need to hop to it.

2. If you are not advertising your products and services online, then you are missing out on Billions of dollars of revenue.

“Online shopping sites offered deeper discounts and pushed new technology to connect with consumers on Cyber Monday, in what’s shaping up to be a strong post-Thanksgiving sales period for online retailers.” -read entire post at the Wall Street Journal.

Free Webinar via ComScore – State of the U.S. Online Retail Economy through Q3 2009

As it pertains to media news, the following is a great way to learn more about consumer sentiment and economic trends. I tune in to better gauge how e-commerce can help my customers and where they should be directing their ad spending (print, web, mobile, direct mail, etc..).

Continue reading

Most Redditors Find Newspaper Website Page Jumps Annoying

Dear Washington Post and every other internet newspaper: if you have a long article, PUT IT ON ONE PAGE. My browser isn’t paper, you don’t need to break it up into 6 pages

As the title of above Reddit thread implies many newspaper news sites spread their longer articles over several pages.  It’s my opinion that they do it to drive up pageviews and advertising impressions, but in the process annoy the hell out of the reader.  While the Newspaper Association of America continues to triumphantly announce record pageviews on newspaper sites, the newspapers themselves are going bankrupt.   Hmmm… It’s time for a new strategy fellas.

My suggestion to these newspaper sites is put the articles on ONE page and increase CPM’s by reducing the total number of advertising spots on their webpages.  In other words, don’t have 12 ad spots on every damn page.   Look at Kottke.org he has ONE ad on that site (via The Deck) and it generates something like $80k year!

In the meantime people are developing workarounds for crappy user experiences by:

1. reading the article in print page view which usually puts the article on one continuous scrolling screen.

2. using the Auto Pager firefox plugin which automatically loads the next page at the bottom of the screen to create one continuous scrolling screen.

3. using ARC 90 Labs Readability tool which eliminates all ads from the screen

4. using Ad Block Plus to eliminate ALL on site advertising

5. using this GreaseMonkey Script make a multi column page

The online experience is totally different then the print reading experience.  Newspapers need to get it in their heads that what works in print does not work online.  Print best serves a Geographic Community.  The web best serves Communities of Interest.  If newspapers are selling “brand awareness” type ads, they won’t sell enough to become economically sustainable.  If they sell ads that result in conversions (sales) then they will realize higher CPM’s.  Newspapers however, must dismantle their behemoth catch all news sites and create community of interest news sites to best position such conversion ads.  The advertiser and newspaper will both benefit.  The current online advertising and user experience strategies cannot go on.

Advertising in the Internet Paradigm is Free or Damn Close To It

Making commercials for the web -from SethGodin’s blog

The biggest shift is going to be that organizations that could never have afforded a national campaign will suddenly have one. The same way that there’s very little correlation between popular websites and big companies, we’ll see that the most popular commercials get done by little shops that have nothing to lose.

Businesses that rely primarily on advertising revenue take note.  I’m looking at you Mr. Newspaper, and MS. Magazine and… oh well you get it.  The internet paradigm breaks traditional busines models by undermining prohibitive cost structures.  I don’t need a printing press.  I don’t need a television studio.  All I need is a computer, camera, and passion.

How will you adjust?

IBD Editorial Slams Major Media

Dying For An A -from Investors.com

Investors Business Daily has a short article in their editorial section today entitled “Dying for An A”.  The article starts out with this line, “From once-revered print institutions to formerly dominant TV giants, the major media are crumbling. And the White House press secretary just told them why, “grading” them a “strong A” — A for acquiescence.”

The article then goes on to explain that “White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, who recently took it upon himself to give the White House press corps a collective report card affixed with a gold star, telling reporters he was awarding them “a strong A” for their coverage of the administration’s first 100 days”.

Zing!

IBD has an agenda and people usually either love IBD or hate it, but you have to respect their ridiculous number of revenue streams, and print circulation… growth!  IBD generates approximately $10 million in annual revenue from its seminar business.” as reported recently in TheBigMoney.

Google to offer Premium Advertising for Select News Sites

Eric Schmidt on Google’s New Plan for the News -from TheWrap

Sharon Waxman who writes Waxword for the Wrap… ugh, we get it we get it, has an interesting interview with Google CEO Eric Schmidt who reveals that in about 6 months Google will launch a premium ad service for “premium content”.  The pilot news outlets to get this treatment will be the NYtimes and WashingtonPost.

The participating news outlets won’t get direct revenue bumps but the theory is that they will enjoy greater traffic from search.

In my opinion and Google’s too, websites need to figure out a way to better connect with their audience to create a community and lessen the reliance on search for revenue generation.

2 More Papers Join TweenTribune

Sandy Sanders, the publisher of the Valdosta Daily Times in Valdosta, GA gave TweenTribune the green light this week. Here’s his page of local content on the site: http://tweentribune.com/valdosta.

David Leone, the publisher of the AmericanNews in Aberdeen, SD, told TweenTribune owner Alan Jacobson that he wants to move forward with TweenTribune. Here’s what Dave said:

“I like the content, the look and I have some ideas on how we can utilize it, not just for NIE purposes but to market it towards that tough age and frankly, the age where many kids have no clue about newspapers or newspaper websites. I do think there is a good opportunity to sell local advertising also.”

Local news from both papers, as well as Norfolk, Bakersfield and Wilson can be seen beneath the “your town” topic at tweentribune.com

RELATED:

Sustainable Revenue Idea For Newspaper Publishers

“What does your audience want from you – and do you know what they will pay for?”.  -from PWC

Many newspapers have not honestly asked themselves this question because if they did they would be the largest creators of business websites in their DMA.  As a consultant I work with local business owners to do things like build / rebuild their websites, add their sites and business to listing sites like Google Maps, Yahoo Local, Yelp and others.

Newspapers should be doing this, not me.  It should be a big, growing part of their revenue stream.  I know of only one newspaper doing something close to this and that is Cox Ohio publishing.  Here’s an excerpt from a quick interview with Internet General Manager Ray Marcano from Cox Ohio Publishing explaining more.

End America East Session Follow up with Ray Marcano:

RI- Looking forward, what will your main revenue streams be?
RM-  Direct sales not tied to print / classified upsells.  Our direct sales are up 30% year over year.

RI- Tell me about your Ad Studio business.  When did it launch?  Who is using it?  Is it a major revenue stream?
RM- We started that business in 2008.  Our biggest customers are media companies outsourcing to COX for ad design.  It is a significant new revenue stream.

RI- Is an online only presence like the what the Seattle P-I did anything your company has considered?
RM – No because our product is thriving, that’s not to say we don’t have stand alone online sites because we do have 937moms.com and activedayton.com

RELATED:

Free Advertising Ideas For Newspaper Publishers

Part 2 More Advertising Ideas For Newspaper Publishers where I talk about setting up an advertising fair for for courting local businesses.

Second Street Media Solutions Owners Matt Coen and Doug Villhard Discuss Upickem online contesting platform.

TweenTribune Signs Up Another Newspaper

TweenTribune is on a tear signing up their third newspaper, in almost as many weeks, since launching the platform.  The North Carolina based Wilson Times is now using TweenTribune for their NIE program and founder Alan Jacobson reports that “ads are running at wilsontimes.com on its homepage and interior pages to promote tweentribune”.   If Alan Keeps this pace of new announcements up I’ll have to start charging him for bandwidth consumption on metaprinter.

Read my interview with Alan Jacobson to learn more about “community of interest” news sites and how TweenTribune can monetize a newspaper’s NIE campaign while bringing it into the internet paradigm.

Metaprinter Tries Out Printcasting

What is Printcasting?  From their site:

Printcasting is a first of its kind online tool that assists users in dynamically creating customized newspapers and magazines comprised of information gathered from local news sources such as blogs, newsletters, news organizations, user content, and other Contributors.  Creating your own publication is as simple as adding the elements you want included in your publication through the easy to use Printcasting.com interface.  Without having to hire a team of editors, graphic artists, or authors you will be able to create your own, professional publication for distribution.

Publishers will also be able to allow Advertisers to place targeted advertisements in their publications and, in the future, receive a portion of revenue generated from those advertisements.  Publications created by the user may then be available for print, download, and distribution to Subscribers.

I wrote about the years-ago-created RSS to print application FeedJournal and it’s potential for a digital newspaper application last year, so Printcasting’s claim to be the “first of its kind” in this realm isn’t necessarily true, what is unique though is their attempt to monetize the resulting product with a simple ad creation tool (among other things).

Printcasting is a Knight News Challenge winner and their website is inviting so I decided to give it a try for Metaprinter.  I want to emphasize that the Printcasting site was in open Beta / preview mode when I did this so don’t judge too harshly.

Step 1. Definitely watch this instructional video before doing anything. Continue reading

The Bakersfield Californian to Deploy TweenTribune

The Bakersfield Californian joins The Virginia-Pilot as early adopters of the Alan Jocobson inspired news platform, TweenTribune. Both newspapers are using the site to revitalize their moribund NIE programs.  The platform is web based, safe for kids, NIE compliant, and monetizable.  If that is not incentive enough to consider it, the Audit Bureau of Circulations will cease to count NIE newspaper copies as a form of paid circulation in the beginning of 2010.   The TweenTribune sites will fill that need.

Though TweenTribune is a niche site for kids, Alan’s concept focuses on newspapers publishing many “community of interest” news sites rather than a single geographic community newspaper website.  Currently, this is a more common strategy for magazine publishers and blog networks, but the idea is to publish many independent niche news sites to focus readership, drive engagement and command higher CPM’s from advertisers.

In an email with Alan he emphasized that newspaper publishers are interested in the TweenTribune platform as a model for lots of niche sites – “…the number we’re throwing around is 1,000 sites. They want to use TweenTribune to test the efficacy of that strategy”. Continue reading

USA Today Launches Another “Community of Interest” News Site Today

In my interview with Alan Jacobson recently he emphasized the importance of newspapers shifting their online focus to “community of interest” news sites instead of geographic community sites; which are essentially general interest newspapers recreated on a website.  I agree and have been pushing the idea here on metaprinter for quite some time as well.

Because of their inherent targeting, community-of-interest news sites have high reader engagement, more vibrant communities, and are better venues for targeted advertising.  Just look at techcrunch or Kotaku.

USA Today launched  MMA Fighting Stances, a mixed martial arts community site today.  This is the newest in a string of community sites that Gannett is launching (Open Road, Hotel Check-In, Game Hunters, The Oval, and Faith & Reason).  

What do I like? Continue reading

Steven Brill, Gordon Crovitz, and Leo Hindery today announced the formation of Journalism Online

Media Leaders Form Journalism Online, LLC
Company Will Be Global Platform for Easy Payment Option Enabling New Revenue Models For News In Time of Crisis

‘Strong interest’ already expressed by major newspaper, magazine companies

NEW YORK, April 14, 2009 – Citing “the urgent need” for a comprehensive, immediate plan to address the downward spiral in the business of publishing original, quality journalism, experienced journalism and media industry executives Steven Brill, Gordon Crovitz, and Leo Hindery today announced the formation of Journalism Online, a company that will quickly facilitate the ability of newspaper, magazine and online publishers to realize revenue from the digital distribution of the original journalism they produce …continue reading Media Leaders Form Journalism Online, LLC

Here is what the above press release boils down to:

“…there is an urgent need for a business model that allows quality journalism to be the beneficiary of the Internet’s efficient delivery mechanism rather than its victim,” said co-founder Steven Brill Continue reading

Interview With Alan Jacobson – TweenTribune News Site

This interview took place between TweenTribune‘s managing editor Alan Jacobson and I at this year’s America East Newspaper Operations and Technology conference.  If Alan’s name sounds familiar it is because he is the president of BrassTacksDesign, which has provided editorial, advertising and technical support to newspapers from New England to New Zealand for almost 20 years.

RI- What is TweenTribune and how did your idea for it come about?
AJ- Lets go all the way back to 1996 when I wrote an article for Brass Tacks Design entitled Online newspapers: Where’s the revenue? In that article I emphasize the importance for websites to build on a “community of interest” rather than a geographic community such as newspapers have traditionally served.   The points being, advertisers would be eager to advertise beside niche content rather than generic news on a website AND the internet is better suited at targeting “communities of interest” than printed newspapers.  Newspapers should have 1000 niche sites, not 1 mammoth site attempting to do everything.

I am the father of two tweens and being familiar with the Newspapers In Education (NIE) program it was clear to me that something better needed to be created for all parties involved.  The current NIE setup is a disaster.  The print product they are pushing not only costs publishers millions of dollars, it is attempting to get kids interested in a product that is going away and filled with adult content.  Their online solutions are equally bad.  Those sites are not designed with the kid’s best interests in mind.  The sites are poorly designed and have wacky logos and colors…  I actually did design testing with my kids and their friends, and my friends kids… you know what they like?  A well laid out, clean site just like the rest of us! Continue reading

WashingtonPost.com Membership Wall

Has anyone else noticed the membership wall that the Washington Post website Washingtonpost.com has erected?  Visit the site, click ANY headline or navigation link and you are redirected to the page below.  It wasn’t always like this and I don’t like it at all.  Every time I just click off, and visit NYTimes.com or some other news site where the info is still free.

If I really want to see a particular article I can back into it by copying and pasting the article title into Google news and then clicking through the search result.  This works for WSJ paid content too which makes me wonder if these large publisher have an agreement with Google, but at the same time are angry about it.

What has been your experience on their site?  I remember being able to read national headlines without logging in.  So while others are going to paywalls, The Washington Post is moving to a membership wall? Maybe just for the time being. I’m hoping this is an experiment that will transform into something better.  I will never create an account and then log in to any newspaper’s website just to read one article and I suspect that others will not either.

UPDATED ON APRIL 9-2009

Why are they doing this?  When newspaper websites do what the washingtonpost site is doing, they are looking for ways to behaviorally target their readers and charge higher CPM’s to their advertisers. Continue reading

America East Newspaper Operations and Technology Conference Day2

Roughly 565 registered attendees at this point.  This post will be continuously updated throughout the day.  Check back often.  Just arrived in God’s Country, Hershey PA for the

America East Newspaper Operations and Technology Conference

First Session (that I attended)

Pitching Your Media Company

Jane Hungarter -VP Marketing and Communications, Pennsyvlania Newspaper Association Continue reading

America East Newspaper Operations and Technology Conference Day1

This post will be continuously updated throughout the day.  Check back often.  Just arrived in God’s Country, Hershey PA for the

America East Newspaper Operations and Technology Conference

I’m not sure if the wireless connection will be available in all rooms but I’ll try and update frequently here and at  twitter.com/metaprinter.  Follow the #AE hashtag for event updates on Twitter.


2009 America East Newspaper & Technology Conference Exhibit Hall from robert ivan on Vimeo.

Also, the conference has it’s own twitter feed at twitter.com/ameast Continue reading

This is how Social Media really works by Matt Haughey

This is how Social Media really works -from aWholeLottaNothing

Metafilter founder Matt Haughey has a recent blog post about ditching “social media marketing gurus” and focusing on creating quality stuff people will write and talk about.

…there are thousands of people all over twitter and blogs that think throwing thousands of dollars at people that describe themselves as a “marketing guru” is the way to increase their company sales. I’m here to say I think that may very well be a waste of money, time, and energy.

I agree with him almost entirely but would say that there are cetain products and services that cannot wait for the “long tail” to promote, like a bank’s yield on their CD’s.  By the time a blogger wrote about it and it got to the masses who would benefit, the yeild might have changed.  Overall great article though.

Digital Advertising 101 for Editors and Entrepreneurial Journalists at Columbia Journalism

Check out the website at www.journalism.columbia.edu/ContinuingEducation to learn more about spring offerings and register.

Digital Advertising 101
Workshop: May 4, 2009
7 p.m. to 10 p.m

Learn about the business of advertising in the digital age in this May 4 workshop at the Graduate School of Journalism. Industry experts will provide editors and entrepreneurial journalists with a concrete understanding of digital advertising sales in order to better navigate business decisions that are affecting the editorial side of journalism. Participants will leave with basic tools to integrate advertising into the consumer experience without compromising editorial integrity or interfering with the editorial product. They will also learn how to perform a self-diagnostic regarding their organizations’ readiness to confront the new realities of the digital age.

Register for this workshop
http://www.journalism.columbia.edu/cs/ContentServer/jrn/1165270051272/page/1212610911553/simplepage.htm

NAA Looks Foolish on National TV

Tuesday March 31, 2009 Steven Colbert had on John Sturm, president of the Newspaper Association of America.  Typical of all his guests, he made them look out of touch and stupid.  As Advertising Age wrote in their blog, “it was hilarous and depressing”.  Why on earth would the NAA send anyone to speak with Colbert for his program?  You know the saying, “all publicity is good publicity” well, it’s not.

Steven Colbert is an influencer watched by millions and he just pronounced the floundering newspaper industry dead.  It’s impossible for Strum to come up with a single retort to “why buy the cow when you can get the milk for free?” and “if you’re serious about competing on the internet, why don’t newspapers have a huge porn section?”

The Colbert Report Mon – Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30c
Stephen’s Namesakes
comedycentral.com
Colbert Report Full Episodes Political Humor NASA Name Contest

Second Street Media Solutions Owners Matt Coen and Doug Villhard Discuss Upickem

Interview with Second Street Media Solutions Co-owners Matt Coen and Doug Villhard to learn more about their fastest growing product, Upickem, which is an online contesting platform.

RI - Simply publishing content on a website is not enough.  How does Upickem bring news sites into the internet paradigm?
MC - By virtue of the way contests work, ie. participation, we make newspaper news sites much more interactive with their target community.

RI - How do you drive user engagement? How do you build communities?
MC - The contests engage a passionate community. “cutest dog contest” for example generated 4.5 million pageviews, 6800 dog photo submissions, over 1million votes, and 15,000 registered users for The Minneapolis Star Tribune.  The users who register to participate in the contest provide the paper with their email info that can be used to drive participation in future contests. Continue reading

Google Takes Out Newspaper Ads to Find Authors

A Google Search of a Distinctly Retro Kind -NYTimes.com

Google was recently sued in federal court by a large group of authors and publishers who claimed that its plan to scan all the books in the world violated their copyrights.  As part of the class-action settlement, Google must locate the authors and grant them the opportunity to opt out of their scanning ambitions, but first they must be found.

Since the copyright holders can be anywhere and not necessarily online — given how many books are old or out of print — it became obvious that what was needed was a huge push in that relic of the pre-Internet age: print.

Google is reportedly spending millions of dollars taking out print newspaper ads in every single country in the world.  Crazy.

Adrian Holovaty Puts Out A Call For Revenue Ideas

Looking toward EveryBlock’s future -from holovaty.com

“…we’ve reached an interesting point in our project’s growth: our grant ends on June 30, and, under the terms of our grant, we’re open-sourcing the EveryBlock publishing system so that anybody will be able to take the code to create similar sites. That’s a Good Thing, in that EveryBlock’s philosophies and tools will have the opportunity to spread around the world much faster than we could have done on our own, but it puts the six of us EveryBlockers in an odd spot. How do we sustain our project if our code is free to the world?

We have a number of ideas for sustaining our project beyond a dependency on grants, like building a local advertising engine and/or selling hosted versions of the open-source software, but we’re sure there are other ways for EveryBlock to be a successful business. That brings me to the reason I’m posting this — we’re looking for ideas and partners who would be interested in helping us figure this out. If you have any ideas or suggestions, get in touch with me. I’m confident we’ll make something happen; it’s just a matter of how.”

How do I think EveryBlock can become economically sustainable?

1. Gannett or Advance Publications buys the services of the entire EveryBlock team to incorporate EveryBlock into their news sites.  Most importantly the team is tasked with creating logical, simple, cheap ad placement on news sites.   The Code remains open source.

2. Go the Firefox route and partner with Google to make their search the default search on EveryBlock. Make millions a year, remain open source.

3. Partner with Apple to to have Everyblock preloaded onto every iPhone and iPod.  This frees Apple up from using popular Google apps like Maps and Yahoo apps like Local. This make even more money when partnered with the applestore.

4. Go the WordPress route and offer consulting and other services.

5. If anyone knows how to make money online it is Amazon.com.  Maybe they can use EveryBlock for geo-tagging their products and services.

6. Make Weichert or some other huge realtor the default real estate search for EveryBlock.

7. Offer EveryBlock and EveryBlog (currently taken by drupal)  franchises to locals looking to get into publishing.

Lastly, I just want to mention that in its current iteration, Everyblock is extremely impersonal and that adding or partnering with content producers like blogs or news sites could add real value via increased community participation.

I’m sure there are others.  Share your ideas!

Increasing Revenue Via Online Contests – Free Webinar to be Hosted by Borrell Associates and Second Street Media

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE                          

Contacts:
Callaway Zuccarello                                                                       
Callaway & Company
Phone: 314.862.4300                       
E-mail: callaway@secondstreetmedia.com

Peter Conti
Borrell Associates
804.360.9434
pconti@borrellassociates.com            

“Online Promotions to Triple by 2012 – Are You Ready to Profit?” Free Webinar to be Hosted by Borrell Associates and Second Street Media

   Continue reading

More Free Advertising Ideas For Newspaper Publishers

The original post from October 2008 Free Advertising Ideas For Newspaper Publishers touches on increasing sponsorships vs cpm, building experiences around your top draws, and improving navigation for better user engagement.

The economy has really shit the bed since my first post on advertising. With that in mind, this article will concern itself with bringing value to the businesses operating in your distribution area. This focus should bring in new business and reinforce the idea that your newspaper has its community’s best interest in mind. The only way this will work is if the publisher and sales manager green light this project. Change and leadership in this case must come from the top down and yes, they should be at the event, shaking hands, answering questions.  Newspapers can no longer sit around waiting for money to come to them.

The purpose of business is to create a customer. -Peter Drucker

When? ASAP

What? I propose a marketing fair.  Think of a job fair, except your entire sales staff will fill their niche booths to listen to their business owners’ (customers’) concerns.

Who? for any business in the community your newspaper serves.

Where? Rent out a big cheap place like a high school gymnasium or holiday inn. Set the event up in such a way that that people can ask your newspaper sales staff questions (all hands on deck) about your media kit, your readership, your services offered, costs, and then get real face to face answers (and hopefully ad buys on the spot).

Why? The purpose is to reconnect or stay connected with your community. Show them you care about their financial well being. Do Not Pitch your products to them. Have your sales force meet these business owners one on one. Listen to their problems, their concerns, their successes and failures.  Let them do all the talking.  Have your sales force take copious notes to find out what your businesses want from you.

As I have come to discover through the services I provide to my local chamber of commerce members, I think newspapers too will find out that most of your potential advertisers suffer from the same problems. Common concerns that I hear?

NEEDS:

1. Newspaper advertising is too expensive and complicated.

2. The cost structure / sizing in their media kits looks like the table of elements.

3. I only want to advertise next to relevant content.

4. I want to market my self, my own website.

5. I did it once and it was horrible, I lost money.

6. I wanted an ad on their website, but they could not tell me where exactly it would appear.

7. How can I use the internet to drive business to my company?

Now here comes your moment to shine Mr. Newspaper Publisher.  Right these wrongs.  Add value to your operation by filling the unmet needs of your business community.

FILLING THE NEEDS:

1-3. Innovate your advertising platform to make it easier for readers and small business owners to place ads online and offline.  Models to ape?  Craigslist & Google ( you know, the ones everyone uses).

4. They want websites?  Build them websites!  Offer the service using your in-house team.  Don’t have an in-house team of developers?  You can partner with a local shop or an Indian firm to crank out quality sites for $300 a pop, add 100% margin and you’re making big money!  95% of the small business clients I deal with need a new website.  Their existing sites are usually real crap.  Build them a site that gets customers in their door and everyone wins.

I can’t stress enough how important this is.  This is a newspaper’s biggest potential new revenue stream.

5-6.  SEE #1-3 above.

7. Some of the greatest kudos I’ve gotten while consulting have come from just sitting with a business owner and helping them list their business on all the free listing sites like Google Maps, Yahoo Local, YellowPages, etc…

REALIZING VALUE:

Your newspaper is now generating new value by filling an unmet need for your business community.

1. You will realize greater print and online sales.

2. You will get a better feel for the needs of your business community.

3. You will create new revenue streams outside of simple display advertising.

MORE REVENUE IDEAS:

1. That unused space on your website’s login form?  It could now be generating $100 per month from sponsorship via your local Locksmith.  Are you The Washington Post or The New York Times?  That space should be going for $1000 per day to Sargent Locks or  ADT.

2. Publish a twice annual town guide distributed to the local community college.  In it you can find coupons and ads for every single eatery and club in your area.

3. Your newspaper now has 3 people on staff to work with business owners to design and develop business websites for them, list their businesses, and learn how online marketing works.   You’re thinking of adding the service to readers to start their own blogs and sites.

4. The success of the #3 above has led to you launching a “SeekingAlpha” type platform for publishing original content.  (seeking alpha pays nothing for the 175 posts they put up every day by the way).

I hope you’ve enjoyed this and it has helped.  Here is the link to the original post from October 2008 Free Advertising Ideas For Newspaper Publishers.

RELATED:

Advertising in the Internet Paradigm

Q4 2008 Display Ad Price Index – News Sites Lower

The Newspaper Association of America reported on January 29th that news sites are growing:

The average monthly unique audience figures for newspaper Web sites grew by nearly 7.3 million in 2008 to 67.3 million visitors, an increase of 12.1 percent over 2007, according to a new report by Nielsen Online for the Newspaper Association of America.  -continue reading.

This is good news except for the fact that Display Ad rates declined at a steeper rate!  I’ve gone over before how newspapers seeking vanilla audience growth for profitability is an economically unsustainable revenue model, so I won’t bore you with that again.  Below is the latest Display Ad data.

Free to the public, PubMatic.com publishes the most complete information regarding Display Ad price performance that I know of.  At the end of every Quarter they publish their research in a convenient PDF available for download HERE, in metaprinter’s sidebar, and on PubMatic.com where you can also find their latest WhitePaper on eliminating Ad Network “daisy chains” for better performance.  I recommend bookmarking their site and if you are a publisher then go sign up for Pubmatic’s Ad Platform to minimize the complexity of selling advertising on your web site.  Trying it out is FREE (at the time of this writing).

How it’s calculated:

The pricing data reflects net publisher monetization via ad networks and excludes ad networks’ share of ad spends as well as inventory sold directly by publishers to ad agencies or advertisers. The pricing data is not representative of the performance of any particular ad network. -more detail in the PDF

Key Takeaways from Q4 2008: Continue reading

New York Times Super Bowl Commercial? – What Would It Say?

This commercial for The New York Times is from 1986. Replace the newspaper that the family is holding with an iPhone and / or Blackberry. Does the newspaper’s value proposition still hold true? What is my incentive now to buy a print subscription? How does The New York Times add to my self actualization?

In 1986 I would read the comics and flip through the entire newspaper “window shopping”. Now I can do this more effectively online. So what ‘need’ is The New York Times now filling and what is the value of that need? Is the it valueless?

Chris Anderson, author of  The Long Tail: Why the Future of Business is Selling Less of More and Free: The Past and Future of a Radical Price, has an excellent article in this weekend’s Wall Street Journal entitled The Economics of Giving It Away. In it he give a great simple example of the economics affecting the pricing power of newspaper content.

Digital goods — from music and video to Wikipedia — can be produced and distributed at virtually no marginal cost, and so, by the laws of economics, price has gone the same way, to $0.00.

If The New York Times had the money, what would their Super Bowl commercial say? Would it say, “Please bail us out. You NEED US!” Has the value proposition changed since 1986?

FaceBook VS MySpace – The End Is Nigh

With high costs, high but questionable cashflow, and dwindling reach, MySpace is looking like a dying newspaper…  When Burger King decided to launch their “whopper sacrifice” campaign they made a clear, calculated selection in determining which of the two social networks was more valuable and influential.

I’m now seeing more and more social marketing campaigns like this which once was only common for bloggers:

MySpace? Not so much.  They’re still trying to figure out how to clean up profile pages without removing customization.  And as of right now, FACEBOOK HAS DETHRONED MYSPACE -from bizjournals.com
Facebook now twice as big as MySpace? Oh boy -from Cnet The Social

Podcast – Video Game Revenue Models To Save The New York Times?

I am Following up my original post below about micropayments with this interview I conducted with GamesOverGirls.com founder Jack Bartolucci.  The purpose of this interview is to learn more about the different revenue streams game companies and console manufacturers use to make money.

Through the interview I learn that money comes not just from selling the games themselves but also:

1. Add ons (like buying new songs for RockBand via their in game store – 28million downloads since Dec.2008)
2. New Chapters (like for Grand Theft Auto 4)
3. Peripherals (like game specific controllers)
4. In-game advertising  (like the ads Barack Obama ran in Burnout Paradise and 17 other games)

And the point-of-purchase is really simple.  Depending on what system you are using it’s either done online or right through the console.  Regardless of what system you are using all the major gaming systems work like E-ZPass. Just set up a one time account with your credit card and all purchases from that point on are transacted with one click.  iTunes works similarly.  Super Easy, Super Convenient.

What newspapers are doing now is not working.  If NYTimes.com can’t break even with advertising revenue, who can?  LATimes.com thinks they can, but they can’t.

How can newspaper sites use these types of revenue streams to make money?  As I say below, I would have paid 10cents to watch the Mike Tyson interview.  What would NYT need to do to get my account info to enable such a “one click transaction”?  How about having the video cut out halfway through at which point you are asked to submit any monetary amount above zero cents? Just like the the videogame companies you would only have to input your credit card info One Time.  After that, transactions occur through one simple click as described earlier.

Obviously you can’t do this with every single article, but you can absolutely do it for every single video and audio slideshow.  Make sure to allow comments and ratings viewable by everyone so people will be even more inclined to pay to view the multimedia piece.  If people don’t want to pay?  That’s their loss, you’ve got bills to pay NYT.

Here’s how Nintendo and Activision are doing compared to NYT stock over the last 2 years.

The interview is safe for work until about halfway through when Jack decides he wants to interview me and we wind up talking about all sorts of things we are not qualified to talk about like Professional Journalism, Sexism, Maria Bartiromo, and Race Relations in the USA.  But it sure is funny to listen to and if you are a gamer and not easily scared by political incorrectness then head on over to GamesOverGirls.comfor more.

[display_podcast]

Continue reading

Washington Post Launches New Blog / Wiki – Misses The Point

The Washington Post Company (WPO) launched it’s newest online venture WhoRunsGov.com today. From their about page:

Who Runs Gov offers a unique look at the world of Washington through its key players and personalities.  Our site will feature profiles of a select group of government officials, including members of the new presidential administration, legislators, senior Congressional aides and committee staff, and experts at think tanks and interest groups who influence how policy is made.

For our initial site launch, creating and editing profiles will be limited to our editorial staff; in its second phase, our site will evolve into a moderated wiki.

I don’t see how this site can succeed in the face of competition from local competitors like Politico, national competitors like TalkingPointsMemo and international competitors like Wikipedia.org.  These three (and many more) are established and have great communities surrounding them.  Additionally, the mere presence of whorunsgov.com dilutes the already smallish pool of advertisers looking to get on politics sites.  Continue reading

Google Eliminates Newspaper Print Ads

Turning the page on Print Ads -from GoogleBlog

In the last few months, we’ve been taking a long, hard look at all the things we are doing to ensure we are investing our resources in the projects that will have the biggest impact for our users and partners. While we hoped that Print Ads would create a new revenue stream for newspapers and produce more relevant advertising for consumers, the product has not created the impact that we — or our partners — wanted. As a result, we will stop offering Print Ads on February 28. For advertisers who have campaigns already booked, we will place their ads through March 31.

I’ve said over and over again, Newspapers need to do some serious soul searching to figure out what their core competency is now in the internet paradigm.  What Need are they filling and how can they monetize that need?  Clearly no general interest newspaper has answered this question.

Newspapers hoping to Cash in on Obama Inauguration

When Barack Obama won the presidential nomination back on November 4, 2008 the demand for November 5th newspapers was astronomical and seemed to catch newspaper publishers off guard. This time around, the newspapers are prepared, but will the demand be as high?  I’m sure it will be high, but will it be as high as the November 5, 2008 newspapers?

In this report, Newspapers to Cash in on Obama Inauguration Demand, Bloomberg lists many papers that are ramping up production in hopes of making a quick buck.  We’ll know in a few hours what the demand is.  Can newspapers hit the lotto twice with Obama?  Yes we can?  Forget the newspapers, The cool kids will be wearing these shirts:

..

UPDATE:

refute the following illogical statement: “Newspapers will never die, you can’t make a scrap book out of interactive products…” -thread on ask.metafilter.com

CNN.com’s K. C. ESTENSON on CNN.com

Can CNN, the Go-to Site, Get You to Stay? - from NYTimes.com

K. C. ESTENSON, the new general manager of CNN.com, has a thought or two about most news sites on the Web: they’re predictable and homogeneous. Seen one, seen ’em all.

Even his own site, he says, could use more of a “unique signature.”

While traffic to the home page of CNN.com is higher than ever, “my hunch is that people go to it more out of habit than they do out of love,” he says.

Alright, so what are you going to do about it Mr. Estenson? He never really says what he’s going to do to increase their rankings.  Also, CNN.com is the highest trafficked American News website already, so how will he measure success?

Slate.com’s Jack Shafer asks for Ideas – more MonkeyFishing?

In this article: Building an iTunes for Newspapers Answering David Carr’s excellent challenge. Slate.com writer and PressBox editor Jack Shafer asks for ideas regarding news dissemination.

“I’m not a fan of the PDF-like editions powered by NewspaperDirect.com, are you? I’ve got a couple of editorial ideas for what a paid online newspaper could do for me that a Web or print version can’t. Send yours to slate.pressbox@gmail.com, and we’ll write the sequel together. (E-mail may be quoted by name in “The Fray,” Slate’s readers’ forum; in a future article; or elsewhere unless the writer stipulates otherwise. Permanent disclosure: Slate is owned by the Washington Post Co.)”

Here is my email to slate.pressbox.@gmail.com: Continue reading

Traditional Advertising Fail! Burger King & Facebook Win!

At 9:29am today Cnet reported that Burger King’s new Facebook marketing campaign has been launched and is quite witty.

Burger King created a Facebook application called Whopper Sacrifice wherein if you install their APP, then delete 10 of your Facebook friends, you get a coupon for a free Whopper.

Already by 8am though, BurgerKing Sacrificial Virgins Group had been set up for the sole purpose of friending and unfriending strangers. Brilliant! No messing with real friends! Continue reading

Follow Up to Eric Schmidt’s Interview With Fortune’s Adam Lashinsky

Here is my follow up to: CEO Eric Schmidt wishes he could rescue newspapers. By Fortune’s Adam Lashinsky

Click and read the article above if you have not already, but the gist is that Google (GOOG) doesn’t have a business plan for newspapers and at this point is not interested getting involved.  At the same time, Schmidt doesn’t “think bloggers make up the difference” so it’s a problem for the citizens of this free nation, USA.

We’ve heard this before from Schmidt when Rachel Maddow interviewed him in August 2008 at the DNC.  Watch the video. He seems to be towing the company line in regards to the newspaper industry.   Continue reading

Online Advertising Prediction for 2009 – It Fails

This could come back to bite me in the ass but I’m going to make a prediction for 2009 that online display advertising and all that other junk like pop-ups fails big time this year.

Why Fail?
1) No one pays any attention to online display advertising. 2) There’s too much of it floating around. CPM’s are dropping 20% quarter over quarter according to Pubmatic data (PDF). 3) The economy stinks. Businesses will cut back on advertising and realize there is little to no change in their business sales because of it. Continue reading

Cincinnati Enquirer Eliminating Print Classifieds – In Line With 2007 Mission

According to this Bizjournals.com article The Cincinnati Enquirer “will cut the number of days it runs classified ads” to reduce costs!! For the life of me, I cannot find the original “letter to readers” from the Cincinnati Enquirer. If any has a link please share it.

Keep the following in mind when considering this announcement from Cincinnati:

2007 Annual Report • Become the digital destination for local news and information in all our markets. • Create new business opportunities in the digital space through internal innovation, acquisitions or affiliations. • Maintain strong financial discipline throughout our operations. • Strengthen the foundation of the company by finding, developing and retaining the best and brightest employees through a robust Leadership and Diversity program.

The word ‘paper’ does not appear once, so it’s no secret the direction that Gannett is taking. Continue reading

Hyperlocal Disaster – East Iowa Herald Closes After One Year

You can’t get more “hyperlocal” than a newspaper serving a population of 1000. This is the purest attempt at Hyperlocal that I’ve ever read about, a very small operation covering a very small population. It has been said before that hyperlocal fails because the advertising cannot support it. So what happened in this situation? Something new and unexpected? Nope, from publisher Mitch Traphagen, “It literally came to an end, the ad revenues,”.

The East Iowa Herald Closes After One Year -from AP/ Chicago Tribune.

It should be pretty obvious by now that advertising revenues cannot support general interest news operations by now. The Krugman Paradox and Publisher’s Dilemma spell this out pretty clearly.

What about donations? What about Spot.us? Barring a generous grant or donation, this model will also fail. Spot.us might be a nice niche alternative for the San Francisco Bay area, but I don’t see the model working for small-town USA. There just isn’t enough disposable income floating around for the model to work. Continue reading

VistaPrint Revenues Will Exceed New York Times Advertising Revenue in 2011

In a December 5, 2008 interview with WhatTheyThink.com staff, VistaPrint CEO Robert Keane expressed his opinion that he is “extremely pessimistic about the economy”.  VistaPrint (VPRT) is a leading online supplier of high-quality graphic design services and customized printed products to small businesses and consumers to 16 million customers worldwide with over $400 million in annual sales as of the last fiscal year.  They cater to small businesses and their average order generates just $33 in revenue. I recommend reading the entire WTT interview here but to summarize Keane’s comments, Continue reading

Would You Prefer a Newspaper With or Without Advertisements?

If confronted with the decision to receive a identical newspapers, one with advertisements in it and one with NO advertisements in it, which would you select?
if your job influences your answer, please disclose.

Clarification added 20 hours ago:

STOP adding your own caveats!!!! This is a theoretical question.

If confronted with the decision to receive identical newspapers (im presenting you one in one hand and one in the other hand), the only difference being one with advertisements in it and one with NO advertisements in it, which would you select?

Clarification added 1 minute ago:

Wow, ok lets try this…. the situation happens on a planet where everything is free. the only decision point is that one paper contains advertisements the other does not…

I asked the above question on linkedin and half the answers to the question are, “a newspaper without ads is impossible”!!!  Thanks buddy.  Oh, wait, you didn’t even come close to answering the question.

ugh…

GO Here if you wan to join this ugliness

As of December 12, 2008 13people have answered.

9 prefer a newspaper with advertisements
0 prefer a newspaper without advertisements
4 people are completely incapable of answering my question

The question was posed after I read this interesting fact: “90% of readers prefer a newspaper with ads”
Newspaper National Network NNN “wantedness” spells trouble

Internet Advertising Revenues in Q3 ’08 Increase – Except Newspapers

The Krugman Paradox in practice

11% Increase from Q3 ’07, Up Slightly from Q2 ’08 Despite U.S. Economic Woes
NEW YORK, NY (November 20, 2008) — The Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) and PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (PwC) today announced that Internet advertising revenues reached almost $5.9 billion for the third quarter of 2008, representing an 11 percent increase over the same period in 2007. While double-digit annual growth continues, the quarter-to-quarter curve remains relatively flat compared to recent past performance. The Q3 2008 figures, published in the IAB Internet Advertising Revenue Report, are 2 percent higher than the Q2 2008 results. Set against strong economic headwinds in the U.S. economy, Q3 ’08’s $5.9 billion represents nonetheless the second-highest quarter results ever. For the first nine months of 2008, revenues totaled $17.3 billion, up from $15.2 billion in the same period a year ago and surpassing the record set in the first nine months of 2007 by nearly 14 percent. -from IAB

From NAA/ Clickz:

Print and online newspaper advertising revenue plunged 18.11 percent in the third quarter of this year — the worst decline by far in the nearly four decades the Newspaper Association of America (NAA) has been tracking quarterly performance. After its first ever reported drop in online ad revenue in Q2 2008, the industry drifted another few notches in Q3. According to the Newspaper Association of America, online paper sites brought in $749.8 million in Q3, a drop of 3 percent from a year before.

From NAA/ E&P:

The number of unique visitors to newspaper Web sites hit another record high in Q3, up 15.7% to 68.3 million compared to the same period a year ago.

The fundamental problem of newspapers on the internet – The Krugman Paradox

Updated: December 9, 2008


I introduce you to the fundamental problem of newspapers on the internet – The Krugman Paradox - named by me after watching PetMeds.com ads appear next to Paul Krugman for three days after it was announced he won a Nobel Prize. I couldn’t believe there wasn’t a better way to monetize his presence on NYTimes.com. Further investigation revealed that the Krugman problem was not unique. Here goes, I want feedback.

Definition:
The Krugman Paradox
is a phenomenon referring to newspapers’ websites and the site’s inability to produce economically sustainable advertising revenue, despite their highest audience reach in the history of their industry. The paradox indicates that newspapers must increase the effectiveness of their online advertising if this is to be their main revenue stream.

Continue reading

Advertising – news venues less effective than all forms of media combined

Below Excerpts from: Experian Simmons Multi-Media Engagement Study (MME)

Only 28% of the audience of an average news program, website or magazine gets valuable information about products and services advertised there, making news venues less effective at conveying ad messages than all forms of media combined, according to consumer research from Experian Simmons.

Among the TV and magazine news properties evaluated, Experian Simmons found that the most talked about news property is The Drudge Report, followed by The New York Times, Countdown with Keith Olbermann, The O’Reilly Factor and The Wall Street Journal.

About the research: Study findings are taken from the latest release of the Experian Simmons Multi-Media Engagement Study (MME) conducted between July 2007 and June 2008.